Criteria updated in 2014.
Coordinators: Anthony Falcone and Scott VanderPloeg – firstname.lastname@example.org
The Harry Kremer Award for Outstanding Canadian Comic Book Retailer /Le Prix de Harry Kremer pour Détaillant Exceptionnel Canadien de Bandes Dessinées
The Harry Kremer Award for Outstanding Canadian Comic Book Retailer
A comic book retailer is defined as a physical store whose primary retail focus is the sale of comic books in all forms.
Shops are recommended by the general public and a separate Retailer Award Committee reviews all materials received and select a store that has shown merit in a variety of categories as outlined below. Named after the late Harry Kremer, original owner of Now & Then Books in Kitchener, Ontario.
Anyone may nominate a worthy comic shop, including employees, owners and Joe Shuster Award committee members, but the nominees must meet the following conditions:
The retail location must be in business for at least two years to be considered eligible
Previous winners are not eligible for nomination; this includes the specific shop as well as franchises or other stores held by owners who have previously won
All nominees will be considered by the Awards Association Executive: this includes The Harry Kremer Retailer Award coordinators and the past year’s winner. Nominated stores will be contacted to provide further information: a written biography of the store and a photo or video walkthrough. As well the shops will be researched online and through use of
secret shoppers, all to determine how well they meet the award criteria.
The criteria for judging includes:
1. Stocking a diverse inventory
2. Overall appeal of the physical store and online presence
3. Customer service
4. Community activity
The judges of this award, aware of the award criteria, are given the freedom to determine their own preferences within the criteria (perhaps they feel that back issues are the most vital component of a comic book store) and grade the shops accordingly.
A four point scale is used:
0 = Poor
1 = Average
2 = Above Average
3 = Outstanding
Total points scoring, as well as debate amongst the judges, determines the final winner.
For persons considering the nomination of a store, here is a breakdown of the criteria:
Stocking a diverse inventory. Providing opportunities for creators’ material to reach buyers is important and this is reflected by a retailer providing the customer a wide range of new and used materials. Special focus is given to the following areas:
large press comics (Marvel/DC/Dark Horse/Image/IDW)
small press comics (back of Diamond Previews publishers)
age appropriate / kids comics
self-published comics / zines Canadian comic creators and publishers
Other materials that support and promote comic books as a hobby
Overall appeal of the physical store and online presence. If comic book retailers are the face of the comic book industry to the public, it’s important that the store put forth a quality image of themselves and the comic industry. We look at:
professional and well-maintained physical appearance
professional and well-maintained online appearance
presentation, including lighting, signage, racking, layout
attention to new comics, back issue availability and collected editions
Customer service. Comic retailing is a broad and diverse business that should focus on providing an exceptional shopping experience. It’s important to stay informed of modern retailing practices as well as building product knowledge to achieve this goal. We look at the following customer service polices and how they work in practice:
Staff members are friendly, knowledgeable, and present themselves in a professional manner
Staff members provide helpful suggestions to customers whether they are shopping for a gift or for themselves
There is a clear sales and return policy, and staff members are able to help customers through any dispute to achieve a satisfactory resolution
Community activity. Expanding the reach of comics is key to the growth of the market. Promoting comics to the community, building and maintaining relationships with schools and libraries, keeping active in social, business, and arts community organizations are all ways to market your business and help you stand out as a community leader.
What advertising have you used?
What in-store events have you hosted?
What charities have you worked with?
How do you engage in community outreach?
Winners are announced as part of the Joe Shuster Canadian Comic Book Creator Awards Ceremony.
The Harry Kremer Retailer Award, is named after the late owner of Kitchener, ON store Now & Then Books. Kremer’s store was one of the first comic book specialty shops in North America and Kremer had a tremendous impact as a retailer, aficionado and patron of the sequential arts.
2005 – Now and Then Books (Kitchener, ON) – awarded posthumously to Harry Kremer, Owner
2006 – Strange Adventures (Halifax, NB) - Calum Johnston, Owner
2007 – Happy Harbor Comics (Edmonton, AB) - Jay Bardyla & Shawna Roe, Owners
2008 – Big B Comics (Hamilton, ON) - Walter Durajlija & Marc Sims, Owners
2009 – Legends Comics (Victoria, BC) - Lloyd Chesley & Gareth Gaudin, Owners
2010 – The Beguiling (Toronto, ON) – Peter Berkimoe & Shane Chung, Owners
2011 – Librairie Planète BD (Montreal, QC) – Carrefour Inc. BD, Owners
2012 – Silver Snail (Toronto, ON) – George Zotti and Mr. Gingras, Owners 2011 – present; Ron Van Leeuwen, Owner 1976 – 2011
2013 – Heroes (London, ON)
2014 -The Comic Shop (Vancouver, BC)